Motor Neurone Disease (MND)
Work and career
Own work and career
Most people who talked to us had given up work, but some were still working and many had continued working for some time after diagnosis. Many of them talked about how important work was for them, both emotionally and financially.
Continuing part-time work as an occupational therapist is psychologically important. Having MND...
Continuing part-time work as an occupational therapist is psychologically important. Having MND...
I think mentally a huge benefit because I can't do anything unassisted now. And I feel that I have more independence at work. I'm in my electric wheelchair in work because I'm actually based within a hospital. It's already designed for wheelchair use and special disabled toilets. Jobcentre Plus pay for someone to assist me because I can't actually do the physical job that I used to be able to do. But I can still use my clinical expertise to assist patients and I think it actually helps them to see me because they're elderly patients who have got a number of medical problems and they're finding it hard to cope at home. So when I say, 'Have you tried this?' And they say they don't like it. I can sort of say, 'Yeah, I tried it and I didn't like it either'. Or I can recommend things and perhaps seeing someone who is disabled recommending things for them, I don't know perhaps they find it a benefit. Perhaps they are absolutely in shock when they see me trundling up in my wheelchair. I don't know but it seems to be going well.
And as I said, the, the support I get from my colleagues and that, and even that it's just that social interaction I get. If I wasn't at work, all, all my family and friends are in work. I would be stuck on my own and the only contact I would have would be with Homecare in the mornings and at lunchtime. I can't do anything for myself in the house so I'd be sat with my own, just with my own thoughts and that's when you become depressed. So it, the longer I can stay in work the better. I know I'll have to stop one day but it won't be without a fight [laugh].
You're currently doing two days a week.
In the summer holidays but when the children go back to school, I'm going to go back to three days a week then. Yeah [mmm].
And they come and pick you up do they?
I'm, unbelievably I'm still driving at the moment. My husband has to walk me to the car and he throws me in the car and puts my seatbelt on but other than that honestly the DVLA and my consultant said they're quite happy for me to drive [laugh]. So I still drive at the moment with special adaptations in the car. And then when I go to work. then I phone my colleagues in work and they come out and meet me with my wheelchair and help me to transfer from the car into my wheelchair then. And again at the end of the day they help me to transfer back into my car and my mother's waiting for me this end to help me transfer back out of the car again. So it works well.
He knew he could no longer demonstrate cars. He worried how his employers would react and how he...
He knew he could no longer demonstrate cars. He worried how his employers would react and how he...
What would have been your anxiety about if the GP had put motor neurone disease? What would that have meant?
Well, if the company had seen it and said, 'Hang on, you've got a terminal illness' you know, I don't know how they would have reacted, you know. Would they have said, you know, 'We're going to terminate you from now' sort of thing, or, 'You...'? And particularly when I was in a job that I loved, which was demonstrating motor vehicles. And you can't demonstrate a motor vehicle if you can't drive it. And of course I couldn't drive. And I'd been doing things like training while this diagnosis had been going on, and I was training other people and I'd got other skills that the company could use.
Clearly, the type and progression of each person's symptoms was important in deciding whether to continue working and for how long. But being able to stay at work also depended on other factors, including the nature of the work itself, the physical suitability of the workplace, how supportive employers were prepared to be, availability of aids and equipment, and the practicalities of travelling to and from work.
Some people felt lucky to have a job they could carry on doing despite their symptoms, while others could not continue doing the same thing and either had to give up work or move to different duties if they had a supportive employer. The Access to Work scheme had helped several people by arranging travel and equipment, though a few reported some initial problems sorting out reimbursement for taxi fares.
He could continue teaching while only his legs were affected. His employers were very supportive...
He could continue teaching while only his legs were affected. His employers were very supportive...
And how have your employers, how did they react?
Right, they, they've basically been helpful. They because I'm a teacher and they made some changes like I would always teach in the same room, which is quite unusual in, you know, it don't normally happen in the college where I work. So that made less moving around And then I also got onto, I mean they didn't do this, but I got onto this organisation called 'Access to Work' and they're a very good organisation. They're much better than the NHS or Social Services. They actually, if you need something they get it for you. And they got me like a little wheelchair, much smaller than this one and that was while I could still walk but I was just getting tired. And that's the first wheelchair I had, and I had that at work. And they also got me a tablet PC which was wirelessly connected to a projector so that I could continue to teach, because it's quite easy to work the tablet PC, you know, you don't have to stand up and use an overhead projector or whatever. So they got me those things, and they're quite expensive items. So altogether that might have been '10,000 worth of stuff. But because I had those things, that meant I could stay in work for longer.
And they also paid, when I couldn't drive to work anymore, they paid me to pay somebody else to drive me to work and back every day. So without that I couldn't have carried on either. So, so they were very helpful. But my employers have been helpful but they, they haven't had to do a huge number of things to be honest, because the place where I worked was already accessible because it was a college and they made some changes. And they've been supportive, you know, all my colleagues have been supportive and everything. And then at the end of the day I've finished work and I, if I'd wanted to keep, keep on trying to work then they would probably have tried to help me to keep on.
So, yeah, so I'm not unhappy with work, they've been fine. And Access to Work is a, is a good organisation. The only thing is they're a bit slow. So again [laughs] you know I got on, I got in touch with them straight away and that's really good because they just sort of take a while to get things done. But when they do get things done it's, it's really helpful.
OK. So they are a good scheme to use.
Yeah, definitely. If anybody's in work they should get onto them straight away. Yeah. Even, I mean, even if, if you know you've got motor neurone disease then you know you're going to need things so the sooner you get started the better it is.
Also tell me about the benefits perhaps of continuing to work, some people might.
I mean I was lucky in my job because it's teaching so it's basically talking and writing. And the nature of the motor neurone disease I've got was in my legs and then, and now it's come into my arms, so I have been able to continue with it for a long time. And there was quite a long time where of all the things that I used to do, teaching was the only thing that I could still do just as well as before. You know, nearly everything else, I'm like worse at, you know. I can't do the cooking and can't do the housework and can't drive my son anywhere and there's loads of things that I can't, couldn't do properly but I could still teach and I was still getting good results and it was still working aand the students weren’t complaining and everything was, so for my personal sort of, you know, it sort of buoyed me up, you know, to be able to keep working. So, so that was really useful to do.
And then in the end I, I’ve finished now because with my arms getting weaker it’s gone more the other way but I don’t think I can do the job quite as well as I used to. And then, because I feel I’m not doing the job well then that’s actually pulling me down a bit, emotionally. So that’s why I finished really. I mean I could try and struggle on but I’d be struggling on and doing the job not properly and that’d be making me feel bad. So I think for as long as you, you feel that, that the job’s helping you psychologically it’s definitely a good thing. And I’m really pleased that I did stay in work I mean, when I got diagnosed I thought I’d quit straight away [laughs] And then I thought, “No, I’ll, I’ll carry on for a few months and get these particular groups of students through their exams and then I’ll probably have to quit”. And then I carried on for another year after that. And then I carried on for another year after that. And all this time I was thinking, “I’ll quit soon”.
Or I’ll have to quit soon. You know, and in the end I have obviously had to finish at some point but by just sort of keeping on going I think it’s been helpful, yeah. Yeah.
His employers were helpful and tried to find alternative work, but he had to stop work quite...
His employers were helpful and tried to find alternative work, but he had to stop work quite...
So tell me a bit about work and how it affected work, and.
Mainly - because I used to do a lot of speeches at work - well, they all noticed that my speech was slowing down as well. I think that's when I went to the doctor as well, just for a check-up. But apparently when I was diagnosed this got worse really, really quick and the walking, climbing the stage all got affected. And about six months later I had to just retire off work.
Did they try and find alternative work for you in the meantime?
They were a great help, like sort of telling me to sit in the office, do the paperwork. But I got to the situation where I could not even sit for a long period. And then my speech really gave me up. But they were a great help.
And I think you said they made it possible for you to retire?
Yeah, on early ill retirement. So because it's a big company I'm, was well looked after. So I think that's a good sign.
So financially, how, how have things changed for you financially?
Financially, I think I'm the same to what I was working. Because of the company and twenty years' service, the pension came out better than what I expected. So it's not like you're going to lose your house, and you've got one big headache. So the work people that way have looked into that, all the bills, my mortgage payments, and then retired me off in that way. And I think they've been a great help.
He applied for Disability Living Allowance but carried on working until he could no longer hold a...
He applied for Disability Living Allowance but carried on working until he could no longer hold a...
So what was it like continuing to work after your diagnosis?
It was okay. I was a golf club secretary. Most of the, the day-to-day tasks I continued to perform. I, I gradually became less and less able to write, which made taking minutes at meetings very difficult. But the club president was kind to me, and the club treasurer, all took notes. So between the three of us I was able to produce a set of minutes. Keyboard skills at that time were not too affected at all. But in the end I couldn't hold the telephone and take notes at the same time, and that was quite an important part of the job, taking bookings for parties etc. And so we decided to call it a day in April 2002 - 3 - 4 [checking with wife], 2004. And it gave us the opportunity to enjoy some quality time together. But from day one I, I asked the club president if he would inform the council of management and I told all my work colleagues, all the members there. I, I was aware that living in a village, rumours are rife. I thought by coming clean and telling everybody exactly what was going on, that would solve that problem, and I think it did. Yep.
A few people were worried about telling their employers or their colleagues. One person kept it secret for two or three years because his company had a reputation for making people redundant. However, most people said when they did tell their employers they were helpful and supportive, and some offered generous financial help with pensions, long term sick leave and paying people a full-time salary even if they went part-time. One person said his employer did not do much to help, but felt that was mainly because there was actually little they could do.
As MND is more common among people over the age of 50, some people had already retired before diagnosis.
Others were able to continue working to retirement age or arrange early retirement. For some people, early retirement was quite welcome, offering a chance to do something else with their lives after a long career. On the other hand, some felt the diagnosis had cheated them of things they had been looking forward to in retirement.
Others wanted to stop work so they could spend the maximum amount of time with their family. One man commented that it was also a question of dignity and not wanting to have to get his work colleagues to help with personal tasks.
He enjoys work but has stopped at the moment partly because he doesn't like asking colleagues for...
He enjoys work but has stopped at the moment partly because he doesn't like asking colleagues for...
I'm not working at the moment partly because of that, partly because I did get quite low. I had a conversation with my GP regarding, as it turned out I was talking about how I was feeling, and it progressed into a conversation about prognosis. How and where it got there, I don't know. It came as quite a shock to me. Whether or not he thought I was fishing, I don't know. But we kind of discussed it. And it was like, 'Oh, my God. Not ready for that.' Crush number two.
Was that the first time you'd really thought about prognosis?
[sighs] I'd known the situation isn't great, but that was a fairly pointed conversation in that respect. I don't do pointed conversations. That really did set me thinking, really, 'Well, if I have only got a sort of fairly finite amount of time left, no matter how nice the people you work with are, do you want to spend that time with them, working, when we all strive for a, a home-work or a work-home balance?' I love my job, I loved my job. In some ways it loved me. I found something that I was able to do and enjoy doing, which many people don't. Having said that, when the chips are really down, do you want to spend your time doing that? And really you go to work to support your home life. And with respect to them, 'No, I don't.' As I feel at the moment I don't, don't know that I want to go back. Maybe when my doctor's note runs out I might have come to terms with things and may consider it slightly differently. I don't know. But at the moment, certainly, I don't feel the want to be spending such a large amount of my time away from the people who matter the most to me.
Would it financially be possible for you to stop and stay at home?
I think when the benefit system starts to kick in properly, then, yeah, just about. We'll have to make adjustments, we'll have to tighten belts and do less of certain things. But it's probably more important to me - it is more important to me, no probable about it - it is more important to me to be around those people and share as much quality time with them as I can. I have to make up for a lifetime without them.
Deciding when to give up work had been a difficult decision for some people. Having to give up work left a big hole in many people's lives, and some found it hard to come to terms with the loss. Some were upset to feel they were no longer so strong and independent, and some disliked relying on benefits after working hard all their lives.
He enjoyed work and misses it very much. He gets involved in other activities, especially...
He enjoyed work and misses it very much. He gets involved in other activities, especially...
I mean I don't know whether, you know, if you enjoyed work or didn't enjoy it, but what kind of a difference has it made to you personally giving up work?
It was devastating. I happened to have very good relations at work with some very nice people, both colleagues of the same grade and of higher grade, including my line managers. I had absolutely no problems. They were always very understanding of the staff, so I had similar good treatment before I was ill and when I was ill. It was really more of a family atmosphere than an office, although it was run very efficiently, and we all had to a great extent good fun - well, if you can call a government department 'fun". From that point of view I was extremely disappointed to have to retire, although retirement in itself, especially early retirement, isn't a bad thing if you have the means, because then you can do things you never had the time to do in the first place. It was, however, a serious disappointment. At the beginning, when my legs were still working a bit, I had ideas that maybe things wouldn't be so bad. Unfortunately as the illness progressed it's now become more and more of a drain. I suppose there are advantages to not working. That stress has gone, although my stress was minimal compared to some.
So it's left quite a hole?
Yes.
And what things have you done? You were saying, you know, it gives you time to do things that you might not otherwise have done.
Well, it does give you time to do things that you might not otherwise have done, but at the same time if you're not able to get out and about as much as you'd like, and in ways you'd like, it curtails your abilities and your movement. I happen to be politically involved and always have been. To some extent I've retained that. Furthermore I have always been interested in various things that go on around me - in nature, in rambling, and other things like collecting little cars and whatever. So I can't say I'm bored. Life is different. Life is frustrating because not everywhere is as yet disabled-friendly. Although the law now states that public places should have disabled facilities, it's not always as easy as all that. The biggest difficulty is going to friends, most of whose houses aren't disabled-friendly, but I get round that. There are lots of pubs and restaurants around here, there are lots of walks and many places to go to which are accessible for disabled people. We have amongst other venues a favourite Thai restaurant that we go to. I've got political meetings and functions that I, or we, attend. So I'm not completely out of things, except that I'm seriously constrained in what I can do and where I can go.
He was proud never to have had a day's unemployment. Realising he was not going to work again was...
He was proud never to have had a day's unemployment. Realising he was not going to work again was...
How do you come to terms with something like that? I'm sure that's something that a lot of people have to struggle with.
Well I suppose it, it you have to adjust whether, whether you have difficulty adjusting, or it's easy to adjust, some people are different. I found it very difficult because I'd always been very fit and very strong and without pinning medals on myself with the, with a dirty job to do, I took hold of it first. I think that if you want to lead people as I had done, you had to lead from the front rather than push someone else into the dirty end and then to suddenly find that people were having to do things for you is, is very hard to, to come to terms with. But you have to or you'll drive yourself silly. When my garden's untidy for instance I can walk past and avert my eyes. I know I cannot do it and I have a, obviously a gardener who comes and does it and, and does very well, but when you want to do a thing yourself and you cannot, that is very hard to, to live with. Especially when you've been used with having strength to spare, but you have to come to terms with it, the other way lies madness. And you can make your life and everybody else's life a misery if you have a mind and you just have to grin and bear it you know? Or try, we have our down days but for the most part we, we just carry on as well as we can. I want to be independent, my family have their lives to lead but as I say without my sister-in-law and my brother-in-law, I'd be stuck.
He enjoyed working in construction, but he had to give up because he just couldn't do it...
He enjoyed working in construction, but he had to give up because he just couldn't do it...
Yeah, and I liked that yeah.
So when did you stop working?
What from there? When I thought they weren't paying me enough money. So then I left there and then done labouring. I found that even better, but I weren't travelling the country, like, with that. So I had to leave that because I couldn't physically do it. That's when I knew, like, when this was kicking in, like, you know? I couldn't physically do it.
How were they when you, how were your employers at the time when you were starting to find it difficult?
Well, one of them I felt like hitting him because he kept taking the mick, like, you know that, I just left in the end anyway. He weren't, he weren't all there anyway so.
Right, okay.
Sorry, I just don't like chatting about it, that's all.
Did anyone, did anyone talk to you about trying to continue working, helping you to find a way to continue working?
Not what, what I was doing, no, because I, if I can't use my hands what am I meant - I can't even write. What am I meant to do like if I can't hold a pen? I ain't going to be able to hold a screwdriver or a drill. So all them things like, you don't, you takes it for granted but once it's gone, it's gone. Well, I did, anyway. I didn't ever know I was going to get this.
One woman originally thought she wanted to resign but found going back part-time really helpful both intellectually and socially.
She thought she wanted to stop work, but she was glad her boss persuaded her to keep doing...
She thought she wanted to stop work, but she was glad her boss persuaded her to keep doing...
So I gave up work. But fortunately my boss at the time was really, really supportive and said, 'Right, well, yes, I'll let, I'll let you resign. But I'm going to keep you on as a consultant, so that you can still do the odd projects and do whatever hours you like.' So I was really, really fortunate. And at the time I said, 'Well, that's fine, but I don't want to do any more work.' But three months later I was glad of it. And it was lovely. I used to come in and do a day in the office and maybe half a day at home. And it was great to just keep my hand in and have that social contact, feel needed and feel a sense of worth, and, but not be dominated by the politics of work and not be bogged down. And, yeah, I, I really do appreciate his wisdom, really, in sort of saying, 'No, you hang on there.' And, and that was great. That was a real, that was quite a huge support for me actually. Yeah, it was lovely.
Yeah, well, I mean - well, another thing that my husband and I found was that for the last year we were, we were in New Zealand, as I say I was much more wheelchair-bound, and I really needed my husband's help, or someone with me, most of the time, or at least I couldn't be left for more than two or three hours. And, and my husband's employers were phenomenal and gave him an awful lot of time off, so that he was either working from home or he just was at home. And, and so we were together for a year, sort of at home together. And that was fantastic, because we could also go to the beach or, you know, do really nice things. But as my mobility decreased and also we lost the sense of a normal life, actually spending a lot of time together became detrimental. And it was actually, we were just getting at each other all the time, and we really missed the sense of normality. I think my husband missed a sense of motivation and worth, because although he was caring for me there wasn't, he didn't feel like he was achieving anything. And so that was one, also one of the reasons for coming back was that we, we wanted him to go back to work and work fundamentally on a sort of full-time basis, and, and then have people caring for me that were paid or, or relatives that could just do what was manageable.
And so that he could come home at the end of the day, tell me about his day and I could tell him about my day, and, and re-establish that normal relationship. And that, that has been great. That's been really, really good, to get that normality back. And so that he's got a focus as well that doesn't - and I'm not the focus of everything, although I like it to be sometimes [laughs]. Most, you know, fundamentally I don't want to be the, the thing that everything revolves around and everybody always making a fuss over me and 'What about this and that?' I just want it to be normal. And that's, that's really helped. And, which is quite counter-intuitive, really. Mm.
Carers' work and career
As Liz (above) suggests, having a partner or other close family member living with MND also has an effect on carers' working lives. As their relative becomes physically more dependent, carers who have not already retired may be faced with difficult decisions about whether to continue working, and how to balance their own needs with the demands of being a carer. Several people living with MND thought it was important for their partner to keep working. One commented, “He's still working, and I'm encouraging him, because I think that's important that he goes out every day, and he's no hobbies. He loves his work, so I think that's what he should carry on doing.” The wife of one man with MND said, “He wanted to get on with it his way. He didn't want me fussing about him. And to be quite honest I needed that escape as well.” Another woman regretted that she had given up work quite so quickly, as they have since found out her husband has a very slowly progressing form of MND.
However, combining work and caring could be tiring and stressful. Sometimes carers were worried about leaving their relative alone at home while they were out. As their relative's care needs increased, some people faced the dilemma of whether they would have to stop working, and whether they could manage financially. (The impact on carers' lives more generally is explored in 'Impact on family carers').
They get up early so she can help her partner get ready for work before she goes to work herself....
They get up early so she can help her partner get ready for work before she goes to work herself....
So it seems like yeah it's not hard work but it's just because you, you've had to get up sort of fairly early for both of us. You know, it's, it's a, quite a long day. I mean during the day of course we're both working and then usually get home about half 5, 6 o'clock. Marcelin - and then I'll sort of start doing some tea or something. And Marcelin usually comes in perhaps a bit later if he's been to, to university and we have a, we always have a meal together and then it depends on how tired Marcelin's feeling. I mean sometimes he'll go to bed fairly early. Other times he'll stay up a little longer but It's, he does try sometimes to do the washing up for me because he can do that, sit by the sink. And that helps you know and it's a, because, [pardon me] because I'm not always used to, because I'm not used to him doing anything. So when he can do something it's really quite nice because otherwise it, it's I find it. You need to sort of be quite organised, you know. Otherwise things get left, you know, and then you're having to constantly catch up like you know if I've left the washing up in the, from one night and then you know sometimes it's still there the next night if I haven't had a chance to do it.
And it's not that there is a lot of work to do but sometimes, you know, if I need to help Marcelin you know just finding, sometimes he's trying to find some of his work somewhere and you know even that it, it's sort of takes you away from other things, doing other things. So I mean it's not a problem but it just means that of course you're not able to prepare then for the next day. So, I do find it sort of quite good if I can keep organised and on top of things and that way it doesn't become a problem then.
The MND Association provides a range of information sheets on benefits, entitlements and working with MND. They also have a Benefits Advice Service for people with or affected by MND.
Last reviewed August 2017.
Last updated August 2017.
Copyright © 2024 University of Oxford. All rights reserved.