Sara - Interview 32
More about me...
Sara, 34, describes herself as Indian, and has been diagnosed with depression and an eating disorder. She says that her mental health problems began in her childhood when she was experiencing difficulties at home. Although she was a very bright child, she was withdrawn and depressed at school because of the problems in her family. Sara says that her mother was dominating, critical, and paranoid, and used to tell her she was fat and a nasty person and put her on diets. Sara's mother made her lie to the GP about the reasons for her depression. Sara took a paracetamol overdose in her mid teens and as a result was asked to leave her school. She was made a ward of court and although she was forced to see a psychiatrist, a social worker, a court welfare officer, and a psychotherapist, she says she didn't want to talk to them because they were not nice people and her mother had told her she would be put away if she did. Sara felt out of control and began starving, bingeing and self-harming.
Sara says she didn't fit in at college because she wasn't thin, beautiful, middle class or white. Sara took another overdose whilst at college. Although she excelled in her A-levels, she couldn't face going to university for several years. Sara achieved a first class degree but felt like she didn't deserve it. During this time, she says she was too afraid to tell the doctor how she felt in case she was forced to have treatment, but eventually she did and was diagnosed with depression.
At one point, Sara reached a dangerously low weight and was very depressed. She began bingeing and stole food. Sara says she was sectioned because her behaviour was interpreted as psychotic' she was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and given antipsychotic medication. Sara believes that if she had been a white middle class woman she would have been diagnosed with an eating disorder, but no one would listen to her; instead she was told she didn't have insight. Sara says the majority of staff on the hospital ward were cruel, although she says she did not encounter any overt racism. Sara says she also found it difficult to relate to a psychologist she saw as an outpatient because she was a thin, beautiful, white, middle class woman. She says that middle class white people look at people's experience from their own perspective and do not understand Asian culture. It was not until Sara was sectioned again that she was referred to a specialist who confirmed that she had an eating disorder and that her symptoms had been wrongly interpreted. Sara says that professionals should listen to their patients.
Sara has found taking vitamins and amino acids, running and attending a self-help group beneficial. However, she says that doing psychological work, following a healthy diet and exercising is hard work. She has decided not to take antidepressants because she's worried about side-effects and becoming addicted to them.
Sara says that her mental health problems have limited her choices in life and wonders whether she will ever be entirely free of her depression and eating disorder. Sara has now been working part-time in the mental health field for about a year. Sara's advice to people in the mental health system is to get an advocate and to keep fighting.
Sara was "thrown out" of school after taking an overdose. (Played by an actor).
Sara was "thrown out" of school after taking an overdose. (Played by an actor).
We went to see my GP and my Mum told me what to say to him, and she was there making sure that I said what she had told me to say, and so I just sort of said that I had classroom problems at school, which is true, I mean I did, I wasn't popular at school. I didn't have friends. I was appalling at games, which makes people very unpopular and yes, so I didn't have any friends and I wasn't, I wasn't popular with the teachers either, but I just said that I had school problems and it was just, it was an ongoing battle for like about four years, between the school and home. You know, they would look for any evidence they could that I was, because what happened, somebody wrote to them and said I was depressed and that I needed to see a psychiatrist. And they picked up on that, and I think because they were a private school they didn't want any kind of problems there. So they just kept saying to my parents, you know, 'If she doesn't see a psychiatrist she can't continue her education here. And they would look for any evidence they could, like you know, I wrote a poem, and like they would bring a poem, a poem, in on subjects, and they would bring it up, like two terms later and say, 'Oh, she wrote this poem so she must be depressed.' And it was things, that you know, it as just like they were looking for evidence that they could find, just to hassle me, and of course it made everything worse at school. It made everything worse at home, because they were going back to tell my parents. And my Mother was getting angry and saying, 'Why are you behaving like this, and letting them think there is something wrong?'
And yes, the whole thing kind of culminated in me taking a massive paracetamol overdose in my mid teens. And I subsequently got thrown out of school, because they said, 'That meant that I was going to be a problem to teachers and pupils and they didn't want me there.' [sniff] And that was when, I suppose, I did, finally get all the input from people who I hadn't wanted to see. I was made a ward of court. I was forced to see a psychiatrist, a social worker, a court welfare officer, a psychotherapist, and I never, you know, I never told them what was going on, because my Mum had this lie sort of ready fabricated and she told me if I didn't tell them why I had taken an overdose, they would, they would put me away.
Sara believes that White middle class people can't always understand Asian culture. (Played by an actor.)
Sara believes that White middle class people can't always understand Asian culture. (Played by an actor.)
But yes, I just, I don't always think that middle class people can understand like, oh and, you know, white middle class people can understand. I mean for instance, like they would not understand Asian culture. And things like, you know, like in Asian culture it's kind of like you don't talk to people outside the family. You know, you don't let them know things, it stays in the family, and… I don't know, I think they, they are looking at things from what is normal from a white middle class person's perspective. And what might be normal for them will not necessarily be normal for me. You know, I mean for instance in this culture it's very much kind of individualistic, sort of go-getting thing, whereas in other cultures it might be more sort of collective community that's more important. I mean for instance like just giving an example, I don't really have very much ambition and in this culture that matters, because we are kind of brought up to achieve and succeed and have a career and be successful, whereas if I was growing-up in, I don't know, an African village or something, it would be fine for me to just, I don't know, you know, gut fish or something for a living and I'd still be part of the community and valued. I don't know, I just…
Sara's eating disorder is in remission, and although she feels a lot better and can function, she still gets depressed. (Played by an actor).
Sara's eating disorder is in remission, and although she feels a lot better and can function, she still gets depressed. (Played by an actor).
And now I think, I mean obviously I am doing a lot better than I was in that I am working and, you know, well my eating disorder is kind of in remission and it is not like I never have thoughts about, you know, food and weight and stuff but I am a lot better than I was. And I'm able to cope better then I was. And I may get better, you know, even better in the future, I don't know, but I still, I mean I still have all the kind of low self-esteem depressing thoughts, like I don't think people like me'
I think I am probably depressed most of the time, still. And, but it's kind of like, it's not really, really severe, so it is kind of like I can function. So, I would say that now I am kind of like a functioning depressive. And I don't, I don't know, I don't really ever expect that I will ever be like kind of people who have never been depressed or people who recover and, you know, it has been my choice not to take medication for depression [sniffs]'
And, I think I, yes, I don't really enjoy things. Even things that I think I ought to enjoy I just don't, I mean I do have a laugh sometimes, you know, with like people, like colleagues and stuff and I am in a relationship. But I'm, I'm just, I'm not happy and I don't know why and I don't know what to do to put it right. And sometimes it just feels like it's too much hard work, just to keep myself treading water, you know, just to be functioning. And I think the difference is now is that I kind of behave better then I used to, And I think maybe that's, you know, in some ways it is because I am kind of better mentally, but in some ways I think it's also that I feel I have to behave in a certain way and, and appear to be normal, otherwise I'll, I'll end up in hospital again, or, you know, and I don't, I never, never want to go through that experience again. It was the most horrible thing. And I would rather be like, you know, in a low wage job and living a life of, kind of a dull life rather than back in the mental health system. At least I'm like a free citizen as it were, now. And I can pass for normal. Yeah, I think I pass for normal. Probably if people get to know me too well they realise I am a bit odd, or they might realise that I'm bit insecure about things. But I can probably pass for normal now, but I think that's probably as good as it gets.
Sara says taking antidepressant would imply that her depression was caused by a chemical imbalance, whereas she regarded it as natural response to distressing events. (Played by an actor.)
Sara says taking antidepressant would imply that her depression was caused by a chemical imbalance, whereas she regarded it as natural response to distressing events. (Played by an actor.)
And yes, something I did want to say was that, I like, have looked on the website and I have seen some people saying that they felt relieved to take medication because it felt like someone was saying it's not your fault, and you have got a chemical imbalance and for me, I actually think, if someone said that to me it would negate all my experiences that led to me becoming so depressed, if they just said, 'Oh well you well you've just got a chemical imbalance in your brain and''
I mean I can see the point why people might think that, you know, if they're told they have got a chemical imbalance that makes them feel it's not their fault and it is a real illness. But for me for somebody to tell me that and say, 'Oh just take an antidepressant.' I feel quite angry about that, because I think that, in a way I think I'm justified in being depressed I suppose. I think well, and I know that there's a lot of people who do have terrible lives and they don't get depressed and maybe I am not, I don't know, maybe there is some brain chemical imbalance but I just think. And I'm not really very good at explaining my experiences in a way that could make people understand why I would be so depressed. I think it's like only if you have lived through it, that you might understand. But I sort of think well, no wonder I'm depressed.
Sara finds middle class white professionals difficult to relate to. (Played by an actor).
Sara finds middle class white professionals difficult to relate to. (Played by an actor).
Sara suggests that professionals listen, not make assumptions, and realise that people with mental health problems have "the same dreams and desires as everyone else". (Played by an actor.)
Sara suggests that professionals listen, not make assumptions, and realise that people with mental health problems have "the same dreams and desires as everyone else". (Played by an actor.)
They need to actually listen to the patient because I think what they tend to do is listen to everybody else involved and the patient is not taken seriously because they're ill and that is sick. So for instance they will listen to the family, they will listen to, you know, anyone like in my case, the manager, or the other residents where I lived, but they didn't listen to me, and I think the person themselves, you know, they, their experience as well, they're the ones who know how they're feeling, you know, and it's not about, whether other people think you are behaving well or not because it's your life, so. And I think it's really, I think it's really important for them to just listen to the patient, which I don't think they always do, you know, and listen to how the patient is feeling. So if a patient is saying this medication is not helping me, it's not making me feel good, then, you know, it needs, but also I think as well that, to understand that they, not everybody's problems are biochemical and that they don't know.
I mean unless they actually sit down with somebody and go through their entire life experience then they can't just look at someone and think they've got these symptoms, this medication will, will do something to, you know, suppress the symptoms and make them more socially acceptable to other people. You know, I think that's something with me, that they didn't know anything about my life, they just took everybody else's word, 'Oh she behaves like this', like, you know, for instance, my Dad said that I hadn't wanted contact with him, and they therefore said, 'Oh that's abnormal and that's a sign of schizophrenia.' You know, do you want to know why my dad, why I didn't want contact with my family. It's just they don't ask these questions, they just assume. They make a lot of assumptions.
Yes. I think it's important for people to have a choice over what, you know, what, what kind of treatment they get. I don't know I suppose to see people as individuals and not just diagnoses. And to understand as well, that people with mental health problems, they have like, you know, the same dreams and desires as everyone else. They're not like, oh because you have got an illness you're just happy to sit in a corner watching telly and, shuffling about, you know. I don't know really, that's it.
For Sara, self-harm was a way of punishing herself but now she feels her self-esteem is better she doesn't want to do it, although she still has negative thoughts. (Played by an actor.)
For Sara, self-harm was a way of punishing herself but now she feels her self-esteem is better she doesn't want to do it, although she still has negative thoughts. (Played by an actor.)
In fact I felt like killing myself. And the only outlet I had for that, well I think the starving, it was pretty clear that my Mum was going to put a stop to that, she wasn't going to let me carry on starving and there were all kinds of threats, but the cutting was something that I could in secret. And it was a way of, I suppose, punishing myself. Sometimes, it was' a way of' if she was screaming at me, and telling me what a terrible person I was and stuff then I felt, well if I am that bad then I deserve this. So, I would, I would cut, because I felt that I deserved it. She was telling me all these horrible things and she would never hit me. And I would think well surely if I am that bad I deserve to be hit and stuff. And so I would do it to myself. And also I think sometimes when I was angry with her, and obviously I couldn't do anything to her, so I cut myself'
I still feel like there is something wrong with me. Very much there is something wrong with me and I'm not like other people and I don't understand normal people at all. I don't understand why they enjoy things. I don't understand why people are motivated to work. Why people have ambition' I don't get it. I don't know. It's kind of like I am resigned to not really doing very much with my life, but then I think I get depressed because I feel frustrated. I think well why can't I do something? Why am I rubbish at everything? Why do I not have any talent? Why don't people like me? Why can't I have a group of friends? Why can't I just have a nice life?
I mean for instance for me, how I used to get my aggression out was by doing things like cutting and banging my head, you know, it's a lot more socially acceptable to go to the gym and run for half an hour [laughs]. And it does help you kind of get out some of your tension and frustration I think in that sense, you know, it is something physical you can do without actually beating anyone up or hurting yourself. So I think it does help in that way, yes.
Did you, I mean did you get any advice about dealing with cutting?
No, I think that' no I didn't get any help on how to stop doing it, I mean I think it just kind of came when I was, well I stopped being so angry, like after I was discharged and I was, you know, being treated for, what I actually had a problem with, and, and I didn't get specific advice for stopping the cutting, I think it was just generally just not hating myself as much, because I used to. I mean I am not saying that, you know, I think I'm great or anything now, but it's, it's kind of like I don't, well sometimes I do but I don't really have that extreme self hate and extreme anger with other people to make me want to do that. So I don't think it was specifically towards how to stop the cutting. I know some people do need that, you know, but for me, it was more like my self-esteem was raised enough for me not to. And occasionally I would get the thoughts, but I think because it has been quite a long time since I have cut, I don't act on it.
Sara started dieting to lose weight, but became obsessed with food and reached a dangerously low weight. (Played by an actor.)
Sara started dieting to lose weight, but became obsessed with food and reached a dangerously low weight. (Played by an actor.)
And' yes, I'd started dieting when I left University but I left University quite overweight and I started dieting. And I got down to a normal weight and I realised that I still wasn't happy so I thought the solution was to lose some more weight. And it went on like that. I would lose some more and then I would think well I'm still not happy, maybe I need to lose a bit more. Until I got down to a weight which was very, very low and I was very seriously ill. But I don't think anybody realised because I was on like income support and I wasn't, by that point I wasn't seeing any psychologists or anybody. And so I was kind of on long term sickness and not getting any treatment, so nobody really realised. I mean people already knew that I was very thin, but, you know, I didn't really talk to them.
And I was just getting more and more depressed, and just completely obsessed with my weight, with food. And my entire days were filled with, you know, I would go out shopping for food and just, I would buy all the stuff that I wasn't allowed to eat and just keep it, so I had hoards and hoards of food. And everything I did every day was to keep me away from food. And I would go out walking. I would go to the park a lot, because that was somewhere that I considered safe because it didn't have food and my head was filled all day with numbers, whether it was weight or the calories or whatever it was. I got myself into a lot of debt as well. Credit cards, I would just go out shopping and like I would be a kind of, I think the starvation made me a bit manic and I would just go on like spending sprees and stuff. And then I think when I got to a really, really low weight, I think it was quite clear that I was dying. I would like pass out, you know, and I would just, and like my urine was coming out red and stuff.
Sara describes the "horrible" attitude of staff when she was in hospital. (Played by an actor.)
Sara describes the "horrible" attitude of staff when she was in hospital. (Played by an actor.)
And they would say that I was hearing voices, they, you know, they made things up to fit the diagnosis. I had one doctor who said to me, 'Oh this isn't a bingeing hospital.' And I had another nurse who would follow me around and go, 'You're still eating.' And then the doctor who said, 'This isn't a bingeing hospital,' had then said that he hadn't said that. And, you know, who are people going to believe? A psychiatrist or a mental patient? So it was like they, they were treating me, you know, there was one nurse would like just push me out the way and say, 'Shut up. Shut up.' Because I kept saying, 'Please let me go home. Why am I here? I want to go home.'
And they were, you know, they were quite horrible. But, you know, I would try and tell my Dad and he wouldn't believe me. And people wouldn't believe me because they were the professionals and he would say, 'Well they're psychiatrists, they're doctors, they've got twenty years' experience. If they say you need this medication then you need it.'
And I didn't really, you know, I didn't have any one to turn to. One of my neighbours would come and visit me and she would say, 'If you don't cooperative with them then I am not going to come and visit you any more.' So it was like other people around me, sort of thought that they were doctors and that they were trying to help me, and they were doing their best. And they actually weren't helping me at all. They were making me worse and I kept saying, 'This is not helping me. It is making me worse.' But, you know, nobody would listen.
And I mean when I came out after nine months in there, of just, you know, I was really scared of the other patients as well who were quite severely psychotic, a lot of them. And [3 sec pause] the whole, I think the whole ward situation I just found it very confusing. I didn't really understand what was going on. And, and I think their idea of whether you were getting better was whether was whether you cooperated with staff and you kept quiet and you agreed that you were ill and you needed medication and I never did. I was always kind of saying, 'Well, I am not schizophrenic. I don't understand why you're giving me this treatment.' And then they would say, 'That's lack of insight and that is denial. You've got no insight and that means you are even sicker then they are already saying you are if you don't agree that they are right.'
Sara has found different supplements and herbal remedies helpful for relaxation, sleeping and reducing her depression, but says they were not a "magical cure". (Played by an actor).
Sara has found different supplements and herbal remedies helpful for relaxation, sleeping and reducing her depression, but says they were not a "magical cure". (Played by an actor).
I've tried various supplements, vitamins and amino acids and I've tried homeopathy as well. I haven't sort of had a huge amount of success with that. And then I've done various self-help books, you know, and some of them have been more helpful then others. With supplements, I think they have helped me to an extent. You know, there's one I take at night time that does help me sleep and it's supposed to raise your serotonin levels. I don't think they have like made me really, really happy or anything. But I do I think they have helped to an extent, that I'm not as bad as I was. I don't get, you know, I used to be, in my really, really depressed days I would just be like, you know, really, really tearful over really minor things, like now I get that when I am pre-menstrual. But, you know, the rest of the time I don't sort of feel like I want to cry all the time and stuff. It's only really just before my periods. I think they helped to that extent that, you know, I'm not as sensitive to things as I used to be. And, you know, I'm not as low…
But I don't, I mean I read a book about, you know, how you can take supplements to help your mood and stuff and I haven't experienced the kind of, sort of magical cure that it promised, and I still have difficulties.
Do you know the names, can you remember the names of the supplements that you take?
I take 5HTP and DLPA and tyrosine and I take omega 3 as well. Well that's kind of general health as well and I take St John's Wort. I've only been taking the St John's Wort since I hurt my back though because I got very, very depressed then. Yes and just like multivitamin and stuff. But as far as I'm aware from what I read the DLPA is meant to like help you deal with life's ups and downs, the tyrosine is meant to be an energizer and the 5HTP is meant to help your serotonin levels. So, yes.